1. Forum
    1. Unresolved Threads
  2. Gallery
    1. Albums
    2. Map
  3. Members
    1. Users Online
    2. Team
    3. Search Members
  4. Dollar
  5. Protest Watch
  • Login
  • Register
  • Search
This Thread
  • Everywhere
  • This Thread
  • This Forum
  • Articles
  • Forum
  • Gallery
  • Pages
  • More Options
  1. Argentina Expats
  2. Argentina Chat

My extraordinary experiences in state owned banks.

  • Splinter
  • May 30, 2023 at 3:49 PM

There are 34 replies in this Thread which has previously been viewed 3,030 times. The latest Post (November 16, 2025 at 9:10 PM) was by Rice.

  • Online
    Splinter
    Admin
    Likes
    2,375
    Articles
    5
    Posts
    15,346
    • May 30, 2023 at 3:49 PM
    • #1

    As part of my motorcycle courier service, I go to several banks to make payments on behalf of my main customer. The bank I go to most often is Banco Provincia which is publicly owned and consequently the employees are paid by the state which is an important consideration in the big picture.

    Most of the payments are cheques but sometimes they are cash. Cash payments I usually do at Provincia Net (aka Bapro and not related to the aforementioned bank) because it's usually quicker, but they don't take cheques at Provincia Net. Stay with me on this...

    Sometimes my customer asks me to take sheathes of papers with multiple cheques or cash and this is what happened to me yesterday and today.

    I should add that the cashiers at Banco Provincia are the least cooperative of any bank employees (or any employees for that matter) that I have ever come across.

    Yesterday I had ten cheque payments to make and around forty separate cash payments, so I was ready to gird my loins for the forthcoming ordeal.

    When you arrive, you tap in your DNI number at the nearest terminal, tap 'cashier' and the machine spits out a ticket with your number on it. In this case ETxxx. Other numbers for different services begin with different letters, you still join the same queue but the order in which you are called shows no logic whatsoever as far as the alphanumeric ticket system is concerned. It's very mysterious.

    When I first started doing these bank runs with multiple cheques/wads of cash, I was given short thrift by all the cashiers and was told in no uncertain terms that since I wasn't a customer of the bank, the maximum number of payments I could make in one go was seven. Needless to say that I argued the point, but it was a complete waste of time due to the passive-aggressive nature of each cashier.

    Armed with this knowledge, I made seven cheque payments to one grumpy cashier then quickly grabbed another number in order to return.

    However, since this was a Monday following a long weekend, the queue had grown considerably and my wait would be hours with about fifty people in front of me, so I then went to Bapro and queued up, only to find that their barcode scanning payment system was down and has been for the last two weeks. This meant that I had no alternative but to make all those payments back at Banco Provincia, which was not a pleasant thought.

    I then killed a bit of time, went back to the bank, waited another half an hour, presented myself to the cashier who proceeded to lecture me again on wanting to make so many payments as if it wasn't his job to do so. He was so rude that I nearly lost it, but I did manage to get him to grudgingly do seven for me.

    When I left Mr Grumpy I found nearly a hundred people were now before me, all holding tickets and looking as pissed off as I felt.

    I then went to the San Isidro branch where I knew the cashiers to be much friendlier, but on arrival the bank was packed and I would have to wait behind another one hundred people which would take hours.

    This exercise had already taken up most of the day and of course banks close at three, so I headed off to another Bapro in Villa Martelli only to find that the system failure was widespread, so I went home for a lie down in a darkened room.

    Today I felt revitalised, so I planned ahead knowing that I would need to acquire at least five numbered tickets because I had over thirty cash payments to make and clearly couldn't use Bapro and bearing in mind the Mr Grumpys loathe doing my kind of payments.

    Anyway, I arrived very early at the bank ready for battle, grabbed a ticket, miraculously only waited a few minutes and managed to get a surly cashier to process my first seven payments.

    I then ran to the terminal, grabbed another ticket but a few minutes later (when I had observed at least a dozen people doing the same) used a different DNI number to grab another ticket, ensuring that the numbers were not too close together, because the new number could have been called when I was at a cashier window and I would miss it.

    This system worked brilliantly and I carried it out a further three times, even managing to get an extra payment past the last Mr Grumpy which made my day because I'd found a way to fuck the system. (you can't get multiple tickets with the same DNI number because it asks you to cancel the previous one).

    In fact, I ended up with a spare ticket which read ET129 and on my way out I spotted a girl looking forlorn, her ticket showed ET175, so I handed it over to to her and she thanked me profusely. Maybe I could have sold the ticket?

    The point of all this is that public employees have no right to be so damned rude and I have voiced this to the cashiers in the past, but it's water off a duck's back. They simply ignore the comment (and you) and wave someone in behind you. But I won't take obstruction under any circumstances which usually results in these cashiers reluctantly processing the payments I've given them because in the end, they are obliged to.

    Queueing at Carrefour will now be a walk in the park!

    A Brit In Buenos Aires

  • Carlos
    Likes
    219
    Posts
    1,175
    • May 30, 2023 at 4:00 PM
    • #2

    Banco Provincia and Banco Nacion are the worst banks in this country, casually they are state owned. All captured by the banking trade unions, another achievement of Peronism and K regimen. No consideration to the normal customer.

  • GlasgowJohn
    Likes
    1,994
    Posts
    5,766
    • May 30, 2023 at 4:23 PM
    • #3

    Banco Nacion works OK for me . Well, it did when Melconian was the CHAIRMAN.

    I told the security guard at my local branch that Carlos was a mate and he pulled out a special ticket which got me to the front of the queue - he then went and told the employee that I was a mate of the main man. Tremendous service. Saved me about 50 minutes in the queue . But then Carlos resigned and a new main man was installed. Back to normal - but I did tell the security bloke that I mentioned to Carlos the excellent service I got in the branch. I still got a ticket to jump the queue , so I cant complain.

    Just for info, I have met Carlos several times and I will be having a coffee with him next week.

  • Online
    Splinter
    Admin
    Likes
    2,375
    Articles
    5
    Posts
    15,346
    • May 30, 2023 at 4:27 PM
    • #4
    Quote from GlasgowJohn

    Banco Nacion works OK for me . Well, it did when Melconian was the CHAIRMAN.

    I told the security guard at my local branch that Carlos was a mate and he pulled out a special ticket which got me to the front of the queue - he then went and told the employee that I was a mate of the main man. Tremendous service. Saved me about 50 minutes in the queue . But then Carlos resigned and a new main man was installed. Back to normal - but I did tell the security bloke that I mentioned to Carlos the excellent service I got in the branch. I still got a ticket to jump the queue , so I cant complain.

    Just for info, I have met Carlos several times and I will be having a coffee with him next week.

    I also do payments at Banco Nacion and the experience is much better. The doorman even gave me a better ticket on one occasion and the cashiers are usually women, who are much more helpful than the men in my opinion.

    A Brit In Buenos Aires

  • UK Man
    Likes
    2,624
    Posts
    11,716
    • May 30, 2023 at 4:40 PM
    • #5

    Yes the wife said both banks employees are very well looked after so don't mind telling the customer to more or less F off. She knows the staff that have been there for years as she used to go in every day doing her mother's bank business. So she doesn't get any hassle....quite the opposite in fact. Even I get a kiss off one of the lady tellers when I'm in with her.

    Now that many of the staff shes known over the years have retired she very rarely uses either bank nowadays. As the younger staff don't know her she gives the other banks her business.

  • Carlos
    Likes
    219
    Posts
    1,175
    • May 30, 2023 at 5:41 PM
    • #6

    I see that I never was fortunate as you in those banks.

  • UK Man
    Likes
    2,624
    Posts
    11,716
    • May 30, 2023 at 6:57 PM
    • #7
    Quote from Carlos

    I see that I never was fortunate as you in those banks.

    Small town so she grew up with most of them.

  • Online
    Rice
    Likes
    1,967
    Posts
    15,955
    • May 30, 2023 at 10:23 PM
    • #8

    Reading this, I’m beginning to understand why people in BsAs are so patient and uncomplaining in queues at Coto and Carrefour. These may hold you up for 10-15 minutes, but not for hours.

    Splinter , it seems to me your client must be big enough to pull some weight with the banks. Could you get them to talk to the top person and say “Our courier will be bringing in multiple deposits every week. We need for you to have your cashiers handle them in one fell swoop?”

    That is an outrageous situation! I hope that at least they pay by the hour, not by the job, so you don’t starve.

  • Online
    Splinter
    Admin
    Likes
    2,375
    Articles
    5
    Posts
    15,346
    • May 31, 2023 at 9:15 AM
    • #9
    Quote from Rice

    Reading this, I’m beginning to understand why people in BsAs are so patient and uncomplaining in queues at Coto and Carrefour. These may hold you up for 10-15 minutes, but not for hours.

    Splinter , it seems to me your client must be big enough to pull some weight with the banks. Could you get them to talk to the top person and say “Our courier will be bringing in multiple deposits every week. We need for you to have your cashiers handle them in one fell swoop?”

    That is an outrageous situation! I hope that at least they pay by the hour, not by the job, so you don’t starve.

    I charge for each trip and also for the waiting time which my client accepts unreservedly. They also pay bang on time which is crucial nowadays.

    Whilst your suggestion is helpful, in the real world of that particular bank, that's not going to happen because they don't have an account there.

    A Brit In Buenos Aires

  • GlasgowJohn
    Likes
    1,994
    Posts
    5,766
    • May 31, 2023 at 10:20 AM
    • #10

    I also dont think Banks in Argentina would ever help out big or small customers. During the pandemic they got used to having no customers and now afterward it's still bloody difficult to talk to someone ( a real person). You have to do everything with the ATM machines.

  • Online
    Rice
    Likes
    1,967
    Posts
    15,955
    • May 31, 2023 at 12:10 PM
    • #11

    What an outrageous way to do business. I know that Argentina has never bought into the attitude that “the customer is always right,” but the attitude of these banks seems to be “Go ahead! Take your business elsewhere! We don’t WANT customers - - they are just a nuisance to us.”

  • Online
    Splinter
    Admin
    Likes
    2,375
    Articles
    5
    Posts
    15,346
    • May 31, 2023 at 1:35 PM
    • #12

    Having said all this, we bank with Banco Ciudad which is also state owned, but with a much better attitude. Our small local branch is very friendly and I can just turn up and ask to see someone anytime I like.

    What I found intimidating about Banco Provincia was the constant human surveillance. Four armed police moving around and several security men eyeing everyone all the time. Try to use your phone and they are on you like a rash.

    Sit over there, move away from here, walk this way etc etc. There is definitely a cattle mentality when uniformed personnel are involved. Perhaps they should employ sheepdogs instead.

    I remember one occasion during the pandemic when I joined a Western Union queue somewhere in Olivos and the security guard ordered me to move two feet in a certain direction at which I blew my top and told him to fuck off.

    He walked away confused.

    A Brit In Buenos Aires

  • UK Man
    Likes
    2,624
    Posts
    11,716
    • May 31, 2023 at 7:02 PM
    • #13

    The missus has accounts with several banks but uses the BBVA the most. That's who I have my dollar account with and where my UK pension gets paid into. I have to say I've only positive things to say about them. The teller who opened my account was great and even spoke to me in English.

  • Online
    Rice
    Likes
    1,967
    Posts
    15,955
    • May 31, 2023 at 10:00 PM
    • #14

    With more customer-friendly banks around, why do any banking customers stay with Banco Provincia?

  • GlasgowJohn
    Likes
    1,994
    Posts
    5,766
    • May 31, 2023 at 10:05 PM
    • #15

    Two positive experiences do not make a summer......

    The general standards of banking assistance are bloody awful.

    The overall standard is very poor.

  • UK Man
    Likes
    2,624
    Posts
    11,716
    • May 31, 2023 at 10:28 PM
    • #16
    Quote from GlasgowJohn

    Two positive experiences do not make a summer......

    The general standards of banking assistance are bloody awful.

    The overall standard is very poor.

    Like many other consumer experiences.


    Quote from Rice

    With more customer-friendly banks around, why do any banking customers stay with Banco Provincia?

    Some people might not have the choice. They could be forced to open an account in order to have their salaries paid into it. Government employees etc.

    Edited once, last by UK Man: Merged a post created by UK Man into this post. (May 31, 2023 at 10:39 PM).

  • Online
    Rice
    Likes
    1,967
    Posts
    15,955
    • May 31, 2023 at 10:47 PM
    • #17

    Govt employees don’t have a choice for direct deposits?

  • UK Man
    Likes
    2,624
    Posts
    11,716
    • June 1, 2023 at 9:52 AM
    • #18
    Quote from Rice

    Govt employees don’t have a choice for direct deposits?

    No idea but I wouldn't be surprised if they don't. Another thing, I'm pretty sure you're forced to pay certain bills,payments in Banos Provincia/Nacion.

  • Online
    Splinter
    Admin
    Likes
    2,375
    Articles
    5
    Posts
    15,346
    • November 11, 2025 at 7:16 PM
    • #19

    If you think this was bad, my experience in Banco Nacion today was on a completely new level.

    As described in my original post, that one was a mere five on a scale of ten. Today was a ten, if not eleven and to say that I manged to NOT lose my rag, is an understatement.

    Tomorrow I'll describe in lurid detail how the day began, how quickly it went downhill and got worse by the hour. I may still be fuming, but the rum is certainly helping.

    Stay tuned.

    A Brit In Buenos Aires

  • serafina
    Moderator
    Likes
    1,239
    Posts
    6,021
    • November 11, 2025 at 10:20 PM
    • #20

    It's seem we oughta cheer that you didn't end up in a comisaría, Splinter !

    My day was overall normal, I rolled my eyes only once when at DHL I asked for an envelope "for my next shipment", and I was denied. "We'll give you one when you bring in the document". Oh, my ponzi scheme falling off! The billions I could have made with a stupid envelope. Bloody arse****e!

Thank you for the support!

Beer to be spent?

Donate now via Paypal*

*Forwarding to PayPal.Me

Donation Goal

10% reached

Hosting by Prostack UK.

Tags

  • banco provincia
  1. Privacy Policy
  2. Legal Notice
  3. Contact
Powered by WoltLab Suite™ 6.1.12
Argentina Expats Forum in the WSC-Connect App on Google Play
Argentina Expats Forum in the WSC-Connect App on the App Store
Download